Man shot during ICE encounter on New York City street still has bullet lodged in neck, attorneys say
Oscar Belgal Remains Detained as Lawyers Raise Medical Concerns After Manhattan ICE Shooting
Tyunews.com – Oscar Belgal, the 28-year-old Dominican national shot during a confrontation with federal immigration officers in Manhattan, remains in custody nearly a week after the incident, while his attorneys say a bullet remains lodged in his neck.
In a habeas corpus petition filed Wednesday, attorneys with the Legal Aid Society said Belgal has been receiving ibuprofen for pain while being held at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn. The filing describes ongoing symptoms that include numbness on the left side of his face and impaired hearing in his left ear.
“With the bullet still lodged in his neck, the entire left side of Oscar’s face remains numb. He struggles to hear anything out of his left ear, describing what he does hear as sounding as if it were far off in the distance,” the petition states.
The case has drawn attention not only because of the shooting, but also because Belgal’s 5-year-old son was seated in the back of the SUV when gunfire erupted on Oct. 8. The child had been picked up from school earlier that afternoon, attorneys said.
Federal judge restricts transfer or removal
U.S. District Judge Hector Gonzalez temporarily barred the Trump administration from deporting Belgal or moving him outside the Southern District of New York, the Eastern District of New York, or New Jersey. Another judge had already imposed a similar temporary restriction on his removal from the United States last week.
Gonzalez also directed the government to explain why Belgal should be subject to mandatory detention. The question is significant because recent court decisions, including one issued by Gonzalez, have limited the government’s ability to hold some people in immigration custody without bond consideration or an individualized review of their circumstances.
Belgal is being held in a segregated housing unit at the Brooklyn detention facility as federal prosecutors pursue immigration proceedings seeking his removal from the country. His lawyers contend that ICE officers took him into custody without a warrant.
The detention dispute is separate from the events surrounding the shooting, but both issues are now central to the legal fight. The court filings focus on whether Belgal is receiving adequate medical attention and whether continued detention is legally justified while his case proceeds.
Conflicting accounts of the confrontation
The Department of Homeland Security has alleged that Belgal “weaponized his vehicle” when ICE officers attempted to block him in with their own vehicles. Federal officials have also said he had gang “associations” and a criminal record.
Belgal denies any gang involvement. His attorneys say the government has not produced evidence supporting that allegation.
Surveillance video from the scene shows Belgal in an SUV when two plainclothes men approach with firearms drawn. It is unclear from the footage what was said to him during the initial moments of the encounter.
The video shows the SUV reversing and then moving forward out of its parking space. One armed man appears to strike the driver-side window, breaking the glass, as the vehicle begins to leave. Belgal then drives away from the area.
Lawyers for Belgal offer a more detailed account in their petition. They say he had collected his son from school and stopped at McDonald’s for an after-school snack before returning home. As he parked, he realized the SUV was near a fire hydrant and began adjusting its position.
At that point, the filing says, a masked man approached the driver-side window with a gun while additional masked agents surrounded the vehicle. Belgal’s legal team says the first man did not identify himself before striking the window and firing into the SUV.
“[W]ithout identifying himself, the first man struck and shattered Oscar’s window and began firing a pistol into Oscar’s car while his son cowered in the back seat,” the petition says.
The petition’s description differs sharply from the federal government’s characterization of Belgal’s actions. The precise sequence of events, the officers’ identification of themselves, and the immediate threat perceived by those involved are likely to remain key issues as the matter moves through court and any related investigation.
Medical care and detention under scrutiny
Belgal’s attorneys have placed particular emphasis on his medical condition. A bullet remaining in the neck can raise concerns that extend beyond immediate pain, including the need for close medical evaluation of potential nerve damage, hearing effects, and other complications. The court filing alleges that Belgal’s face remains numb and that sounds in one ear seem distant.
No immediate public response from ICE was available after the latest filing. The agency’s handling of medical treatment, detention conditions, and the legal basis for holding Belgal may all receive further scrutiny as the case develops.
The shooting has also intensified broader tensions in New York City over federal immigration enforcement. Footage of the confrontation prompted protests and criticism from city residents and officials, while federal authorities have defended their effort to arrest Belgal.
For now, the temporary court order means Belgal cannot be deported or transferred outside the specified New York and New Jersey districts. The litigation will determine whether that protection remains in place, whether he is entitled to a bond hearing, and how his claimed medical needs will be addressed while he remains in federal custody.
Related Reading
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Man shot during ICE encounter on New?Man shot during ICE encounter on New is the main topic of this guide. The article explains the context, practical details, and next steps readers should understand.
Why does Man shot during ICE encounter on New matter?Man shot during ICE encounter on New matters because readers are looking for a useful answer, not just a short summary. Good content should match search intent and help them decide what to do next.